Dave / Gordon,
I see where you are both coming from, but wouldn't this forum be a lot quieter if people felt there was no point replying to a question because of the potential consequences. I would say that unless you are an Instructor, you shouldn't instruct, but is advice the same? I for one would not take the advise of one person alone, unless I knew something of that persons experience. To advise or recommend is not to instruct, is it?
I believe there are other forums where posts are monitored and anything that is incorrect would be removed. I think the way things work here is self monitoring; if someone says or states something that is considered incorrect, another person will usually make a comment about it.
I think it is good that a question can turn into a discussion, I do however think that all people should recieve training.
Jon
Dave you are infact right here- Liability is an issue. Unless you are a qualified instructor you shouldn't be giving advice. If you are a BHPA Club Coach, you can 'coach' a BHPA club member, providing they have a BHPA rating already.
I've noticed a lot of people on this forum giving advice- desipite some very low hours, no rating or formal qualifications, and very little experience- you do need to be careful.
The situation in the Repulic of Ireland, forces potential pilots to go to a recognised school to get a rating, before applying for their exemption certificate- this is by far a better system than the UK. More awkard, and certainly more work, but we don't get people asking if it's safe to land in 'wind shadow'.........